Unlocking the Enigma of Matter’s Existence: Unprecedented Study Sheds Light on Electron Asymmetry

Unlocking the Enigma of Matter’s Existence: Unprecedented Study Sheds Light on Electron Asymmetry

In an extraordinary endeavor to elucidate the origins of matter, researchers have undertaken a groundbreaking precision measurement of the electric dipole moment (eEDM) of electrons. The quest was to uncover potential asymmetry that could account for the existence of matter. Despite achieving unprecedented precision, the results unveiled the symmetrical nature of electrons, devoid of any discernible asymmetry. While not providing an absolute answer, this study pushes the boundaries of our comprehension regarding the fundamental essence of the universe and indicates alternative avenues for investigating such phenomena, circumventing the need for expensive particle accelerators.

JILA Physicists Achieve Unprecedented Measurement of Crucial Electron Characteristic

During the nascent stages of our universe, an immense number of protons, neutrons, and electrons materialized alongside their antimatter counterparts. As the universe expanded and cooled, the majority of these particles of matter and antimatter collided, annihilating one another and leaving only luminous photons in their wake.

Had the universe been perfectly symmetrical, with an equal balance of matter and antimatter, that would have marked the end of the tale, rendering our existence impossible. Yet, there must have existed a slight disparity—an excess of protons, neutrons, and electrons—that engendered the formation of atoms, molecules, stars, planets, galaxies, and ultimately, life forms like ourselves.

Electrons, composed of negative electrical charge, have become the subject of investigation at JILA, where scientists strive to gauge the uniform distribution of this charge between the electron’s north and south poles. Any irregularity in this distribution would imply that electrons lack perfect roundness, offering evidence of an asymmetry during the early stages of the universe, leading to the formation of matter. The Cornell Group at JILA scrutinized the behavior of electrons within molecules as they manipulated the magnetic field surrounding them, aiming to identify any shifts in electron properties. Credit: JILA/Steven Burrows

“If the universe had been flawlessly symmetrical, only light would remain. This marks an immensely significant moment in history. Suddenly, the universe is filled with matter, and we are left pondering the reason,” emphasized NIST/JILA Fellow Eric Cornell. “Why do we observe this asymmetry?”

Mathematical theories and equations that describe our universe inherently demand symmetry. Particle theorists have meticulously refined these theories to confront the presence of asymmetry. However, without empirical evidence, these theories remain mere mathematical constructs, as Cornell explains. Consequently, experimental physicists, including his research group at JILA, have directed their focus toward probing fundamental particles such as electrons for signs of asymmetry.

Now, the JILA research group has accomplished an extraordinary feat by achieving a record-breaking measurement of electrons, thereby narrowing down the search for the origins of this asymmetry. Their remarkable findings have been published in the journal Science. JILA, a collaborative effort between the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the University of Colorado Boulder, served as the platform for this momentous undertaking.

“This marks an immensely significant moment in history. Suddenly, the universe is filled with matter, and we are left pondering the reason.”
— NIST/JILA Fellow Eric Cornell

The electron’s electric dipole moment (eEDM) stands as one promising avenue for unearthing evidence of asymmetry. Since electrons carry negative electric charge, the eEDM indicates how uniformly this charge is distributed between the electron’s north and south poles. Any nonzero measurement of eEDM would confirm the presence of asymmetry, as the electron would exhibit an egg-shaped rather than perfectly circular form. Yet, the magnitude of this deviation remains unknown.

“We must refine our mathematical models to align them more closely with reality,” stated Tanya Roussy, a graduate student in Cornell’s research group at JILA. “We are actively seeking potential locations for this asymmetry to gain insight into its origins. As fundamental particles, electrons and their symmetry offer valuable clues about the universe’s inherent symmetry.”

Cornell, Roussy, and their team at NIST and JILA have recently achieved a significant breakthrough by setting a new record for precision in measuring eEDM, surpassing previous attempts by a factor of 2.4.

Just how precise is their achievement? Roussy elucidated that if an electron were scaled to the size of Earth, their study revealed any existing asymmetry to be smaller than the radius of an atom.

Undoubtedly, attaining such extraordinary precision in measurement is an immensely challenging endeavor. Therefore, the research group had to employ innovative strategies. They focused on examining molecules of hafnium fluoride, subjecting them to a strong electric field. Non-round electrons within the molecules would strive to align themselves with the field, resulting in internal shifts. Conversely, perfectly round electrons would remain unaffected.

By utilizing an ultraviolet laser, the researchers removed electrons from the molecules, generating a set of positively charged ions that were subsequently trapped. Through alternating the electromagnetic field surrounding the trap, the molecules were coerced into either aligning or not aligning with the field. Lasers were then employed to measure the energy levels of the two groups. If discrepancies emerged between the energy levels, this would indicate the presence of asymmetrical electrons.

Their experimental setup granted longer measurement durations compared to prior attempts, thereby enhancing sensitivity. Nevertheless, the team’s measurements indicated that the electrons exhibited no alterations in energy levels, suggesting that, to the best of our present capabilities, electrons possess a spherical nature.

Cornell emphasizes that there is no guarantee of detecting a nonzero measurement of eEDM. Nevertheless, achieving this level of precision through a tabletop experiment stands as a remarkable accomplishment. It underscores the fact that expensive particle accelerators are not the sole means of exploring the fundamental questions pertaining to the universe. Countless avenues remain to be explored. While the research group did not uncover asymmetry, their findings will propel the field to persist in its pursuit of answers regarding the asymmetry of the early universe.

“To the best of our measurement, we have found the electron to be symmetrical. A nonzero result would have been monumental,” added Roussy. “The most promising approach is for teams of scientists across the globe to explore various options. As long as we continue pursuing truth through measurement, someone will eventually unearth it.”

Reference: “An improved bound on the electron’s electric dipole moment” by Tanya S. Roussy, Luke Caldwell, Trevor Wright, William B. Cairncross, Yuval Shagam, Kia Boon Ng, Noah Schlossberger, Sun Yool Park, Anzhou Wang, Jun Ye and Eric A. Cornell, 6 July 2023, Science.
DOI: 10.1126/science.adg4084

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about electron asymmetry

More about electron asymmetry

• Science: An improved bound on the electron’s electric dipole moment
• JILA: JILA physicists make record-breaking measurement of a key electron property