A Deeper Understanding: How Coffee Outperforms Pure Caffeine in Neurological Impact

Researchers from Portugal have presented a study that illuminates the unique neural activation patterns triggered by drinking coffee, including the stimulation of areas responsible for alertness, working memory, and goal-directed actions, that surpass the effects of mere caffeine intake. This finding suggests that coffee’s distinct advantages might be due to factors beyond its caffeine concentration, possibly including the ritual of coffee drinking or alleviation of withdrawal symptoms.

The researchers observed that the morning jolt many people derive from their cup of coffee isn’t quite reproduced by caffeine alone.

In a comparison study between coffee and pure caffeine, it was found that caffeine alone only partially replicates the neural impacts of a coffee cup, activating the brain regions responsible for alertness but failing to stimulate areas related to working memory and goal-oriented behavior.

For numerous individuals, the day kicks off only when the coffee mug is drained. The stimulating effect of coffee, often attributed to increased alertness, leads people to consume it to wake up and boost their productivity. The Portuguese researchers engaged in this study aimed to discern whether this arousal effect was solely attributed to caffeine or if the act of coffee drinking played a part.

“Many anticipate that coffee heightens alertness and psychomotor functioning,” stated Prof Nuno Sousa from the University of Minho, the study’s corresponding author published in Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience, where he also serves as Field Chief Editor. “Greater understanding of the biological mechanisms at work can reveal the factors that might influence them and potential benefits thereof.”

Investigating the Caffeine Boost

The scientists enlisted participants who consumed at least one coffee cup daily and asked them to avoid caffeinated food and beverages for a minimum of three hours preceding the study. The participants were interviewed for sociodemographic data collection, followed by two brief functional MRI scans before and after consuming caffeine or a standardized coffee cup. During these scans, participants were advised to relax and allow their minds to wander.

Given the known neurochemical responses to coffee consumption, the researchers anticipated the functional MRI scans to show enhanced network integration in the prefrontal cortex (linked with executive memory) and the default mode network (involved in introspection and self-reflection) among coffee drinkers. The results revealed that both coffee and caffeine consumption reduced the connectivity of the default mode network, suggesting preparedness to transition from rest to task-oriented activities.

Rising and Shining

However, coffee intake also amplified connectivity in the higher visual network and the right executive control network – brain areas linked with working memory, cognitive control, and goal-oriented behavior. This effect was not observed in caffeine-only consumers. Essentially, if you desire to feel not merely alert but also geared up, mere caffeine won’t suffice – the full coffee experience is necessary.

“Acute coffee consumption diminished the functional connectivity within the default mode network – associated with self-referential processes during rest,” explained Dr. Maria Picó-Pérez of Jaume I University, the primary author. “Functional connectivity also decreased between the somatosensory/motor networks and the prefrontal cortex, whereas it increased in regions of the higher visual and right executive control networks post-coffee intake. In simpler terms, after drinking coffee, subjects were more action-ready and responsive to external stimuli.”

Picó-Pérez added, “While some effects we identified were replicated by caffeine, suggesting other caffeinated drinks might share these effects, others were exclusive to coffee drinking, possibly influenced by factors like the unique aroma and taste of coffee, or the psychological expectations tied to its consumption.”

The study authors noted that these benefits could potentially be obtained from drinking decaffeinated coffee, as the study couldn’t differentiate between effects from the drinking experience alone or those combined with caffeine intake. Another hypothesis proposed that the perceived benefits among coffee drinkers might result from withdrawal symptom relief, which this study didn’t examine.

“Changes in connectivity were analyzed during a resting-state sequence. Associations with psychological and cognitive processes are inferred from the typical functions assigned to the identified regions and networks, but direct testing was not conducted,” Sousa warned. “Moreover, individual variations in caffeine metabolism among participants could be an intriguing area for future exploration.”

Reference: “Coffee consumption decreases the connectivity of the posterior Default Mode Network (DMN) at rest” by Maria Picó-Pérez, Ricardo Magalhães, Madalena Esteves, Rita Vieira, Teresa C. Castanho, Liliana Amorim, Mafalda Sousa, Ana Coelho, Pedro S. Moreira, Rodrigo A. Cunha and Nuno Sousa, 28 June 2023, Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience.
DOI: 10.3389/fnbeh.2023.1176382

Funding: Institute for the Scientific Information on Coffee, Northern Portugal Regional Operational Program.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Neurological Effects of Coffee

More about Neurological Effects of Coffee

• Coffee Consumption and the Brain
• The Effect of Caffeine on Working Memory Load-Related Brain Activation in Middle-Aged Males
• Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience
• The Neurological Effects of Caffeine