Challenging Evolutionary Assumptions: Study on Static Traits in Lizards Questions Conventional Wisdom in Evolutionary Biology

by Manuel Costa
paradox of stasis

Challenging Evolutionary Assumptions: Study on Static Traits in Lizards Questions Conventional Wisdom in Evolutionary Biology

Investigating Evolutionary Stagnation with Anole Lizards

Credit: Jon Suh

Through a three-year observational study involving tracking technology affixed to lizard legs, James Stroud from the Georgia Institute of Technology has shed light on why many species remain morphologically consistent over geological time scales, seemingly contradicting Charles Darwin’s postulation of continuous evolution.

Charles Darwin theorized that constant evolutionary changes lead species to adapt in the struggle for existence. However, skeptics among his contemporaries questioned this claim. They wondered how it was possible for identical fossils of the same species, located in the same geographic area but separated by 50 million years, to exist if evolution is ceaseless.

The landscape of evolutionary biology underwent a significant shift in the past four decades, with a multitude of studies demonstrating that evolution could occur at an accelerated pace, even between successive generations. While these findings excited scholars in the field, they also reinforced the original conundrum: Why do the majority of species remain unchanged over extensive periods of geological time?

Decoding Evolutionary Stasis

Credit: Day’s Edge Prods

This contradiction is commonly known as the “paradox of stasis,” a topic James Stroud, an assistant professor in the School of Biological Sciences at the Georgia Institute of Technology, aimed to explore. Stroud’s comprehensive field study examined the natural evolutionary process across multiple lizard species and potentially identified a solution to one of the most puzzling challenges in evolutionary biology.

The research was featured prominently in the Proceedings of the Natural Academy of Sciences.

Addressing the Contradiction

“The term paradox is apt here because the phenomenon appears counterintuitive,” Stroud observed. “The prevailing hypothesis has been that natural selection operates to maintain the average phenotype of a species, yet empirical studies almost invariably fail to detect such ‘stabilizing’ selection.”

Field Research on Lizard Populations

Stroud initiated a meticulous field study involving four distinct species of Anolis lizards on a minor island located within the Fairchild Tropical Botanic Gardens in Coral Gables, Florida. Over five separate phases, Stroud caught and monitored each lizard on the island, meticulously documenting their survival rates.

Working around the clock, Stroud and his team utilized specialized fishing poles equipped with minute lassos to carefully capture the lizards. After documenting each lizard’s original location, they took a series of measurements including head size, leg length, body mass, and even the adhesive qualities of the lizard’s toes.

Periodic Monitoring and Data Analysis

Every six months over the course of three years, Stroud and his team revisited the study, capturing the same individual lizards for updated measurements and tracking which ones survived. By collating data across various time frames, Stroud was able to correlate physical traits with survival rates, thereby gaining a holistic understanding of how natural selection acted on the lizard community.

Unexpectedly, Stroud discovered that the supposed “stabilizing” form of natural selection was exceedingly uncommon. Instead, the form and criteria for survival among the lizards varied substantially over time. In some years, lizards with longer legs had better survival rates, while in other years, those with shorter legs were more likely to survive. At times, no discernable pattern was evident.

Unprecedented Findings and Implications

Stroud’s study broke new ground by offering unparalleled insights into the mechanics of selection at a community level, achieved through an unprecedented level of detail. Typically, the scientific community hesitates to engage in long-term field studies due to the significant resources required, which has led to limited understanding of community-level evolution.

“Evolution is not a stagnant process, even if phenotypic traits appear unchanging over long durations,” Stroud remarked. “It is crucial to our comprehensive understanding of life on Earth, not only for comprehending the distribution and characteristics of flora and fauna but also for understanding how life adapts in a human-dominated world.”

According to Stroud, the scarcity of long-term field studies has given rise to a skewed perception of evolutionary processes.

“For many years, evolutionary biologists have been grappling with the perplexity of the paradox of stasis,” said Stroud. “This study suggests that the solution may not be overly complex; it simply necessitated a sufficiently long study in a natural environment to uncover it.”

Reference: “Fluctuating selection maintains distinct species phenotypes in an ecological community in the wild” by Stroud, J.T., et al., 9 October 2023, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2222071120

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about paradox of stasis

What is the main focus of James Stroud’s study?

The main focus of James Stroud’s study is to explore the “paradox of stasis,” a puzzling phenomenon in evolutionary biology where many species appear morphologically consistent over extended periods, despite the theory of constant evolution. The study aims to resolve this apparent contradiction through a meticulous, long-term field study on Anolis lizards.

What is the “paradox of stasis”?

The “paradox of stasis” refers to the puzzling observation that many species remain morphologically unchanged over geological time scales, even when theories of evolution suggest they should be continuously evolving. This paradox has been a subject of debate and inquiry among evolutionary biologists.

Where was the field study conducted?

The field study was conducted on a small island within the Fairchild Tropical Botanic Gardens in Coral Gables, Florida.

What methods were used to capture and study the lizards?

Stroud and his team used specialized fishing poles equipped with tiny lassos to capture the lizards. Once captured, a series of measurements were taken, including head size, leg length, body mass, and the adhesive qualities of the lizard’s toes. These lizards were then monitored over a period of three years.

How often was the data collected?

Data was collected every six months over a three-year period. The same individual lizards were captured for updated measurements and survival tracking.

What were the key findings of the study?

One of the key findings was that the commonly assumed “stabilizing” form of natural selection was exceedingly rare. Instead, the criteria for survival among the lizards varied substantially over time. Overall, natural selection was found to be extremely variable, effectively maintaining species’ traits across the studied period.

How does this study contribute to the field of evolutionary biology?

This study breaks new ground by offering unprecedented insights into how natural selection works at a community level. It suggests that long-term field studies are necessary to fully understand the mechanisms of evolution, and challenges the notion that stabilizing selection is the primary force maintaining species’ traits over time.

Who published the study and where can it be found?

The study was published in the Proceedings of the Natural Academy of Sciences and can be accessed through their archives, with the DOI reference 10.1073/pnas.2222071120.

More about paradox of stasis

You may also like


EvoExpert October 9, 2023 - 8:59 pm

A very thorough article, but im curious why it took so long to come up with a study like this? I mean, the paradox of stasis has been known for a while, right?

CuriousMindy October 9, 2023 - 11:44 pm

didn’t know a small animal like a lizard could challenge something as big as evolution theories. Makes me wonder what else we’re missing in the grand scheme of things.

DarwinsDescendant October 10, 2023 - 2:50 am

Excellent read! it’s amazing how one study can turn our understanding of evolution upside down. or maybe it’s setting it right? Either way, hats off to Stroud.

JohnDoe123 October 10, 2023 - 3:02 am

Wow, this is really eye-opening! Always thought evolution was kinda a straight path, but this shows its more like a zigzag, lol. So much for survival of the fittest, huh?

Skeptic_Al October 10, 2023 - 5:14 am

Ok, but how do we know this isn’t just an anomaly? One study doesn’t necessarily mean the rulebook for evolution gets rewritten, y’know?

LizLover October 10, 2023 - 9:04 am

Lizards rule, evolution drools! jk, but seriously, who knew these little guys had so much to teach us? Stroud for the win!

BioGeek99 October 10, 2023 - 11:20 am

This is serious stuff, mind blown! Kudos to Stroud and team for spending 3 years catching lizards. The dedication is unreal. Never knew science could be this adventurous.

ScienceFanatic October 10, 2023 - 1:32 pm

The attention to detail here is phenomenal. Every lizard had a tag, was monitored for three years, and even the size of their toepads were studied. Talk bout dedication!

TechieTalk October 10, 2023 - 3:55 pm

I wonder how they managed the data? Three years worth of lizard stats sounds like a big data problem to me. Would love to see a follow-up on that.

GreenThumb October 10, 2023 - 4:14 pm

Finally someone’s giving these little creatures the attention they deserve! Makes me think twice about the lizards in my backyard. Maybe they’re not so simple after all.


Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

SciTechPost is a web resource dedicated to providing up-to-date information on the fast-paced world of science and technology. Our mission is to make science and technology accessible to everyone through our platform, by bringing together experts, innovators, and academics to share their knowledge and experience.


Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts, tips & new photos. Let's stay updated!

© 2023 SciTechPost